Process
A16(1) — you must answer truthfully and give the documents asked for
Short answer
A16(1) is a rule in Canada's immigration law. It says you must answer an officer's questions truthfully. You must also give the documents the officer reasonably asks for.
You can ask IRCC for your own notes yourself, free. Or we can do it for you: CAIPS Notes + Application File, ₹949C$59US$45, GST includedthe total we charge. See what is included.
This needs care. A quick reply or a quick new application is not enough.
What does A16(1) say?
IRCC tells its officers that refusal letters “should refer to the appropriate legislative provision(s)”. So the code on your letter points to a rule in the law. These are its exact words.
The law IRPA s. 16(1), (1.1) and (2)
16 (1) A person who makes an application must answer truthfully all questions put to them for the purpose of the examination and must produce a visa and all relevant evidence and documents that the officer reasonably requires.
(1.1) A person who makes an application must, on request of an officer, appear for an examination.
(2) In the case of a foreign national,
(a) the relevant evidence referred to in subsection (1) includes photographic and fingerprint evidence; and
(b) subject to the regulations, the foreign national must submit to a medical examination.
Exact words, text current to 3 September 2026. Read it on the Justice Laws website (opens in a new tab)
You may also see it written as: A16(1) · 16(1) · subsection 16(1) of the IRPA · section 16(1) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act · IRPA 16(1)
What does A16(1) mean for you?
A16(1) sets two duties for every applicant. First, answer every question truthfully. Second, give the documents and evidence the officer reasonably asks for.
If a refusal cites A16(1), the officer saw a problem with an answer or document. For example, an answer seemed untrue, or a requested document did not arrive.
The law says you must produce “all relevant evidence and documents that the officer reasonably requires”. So send what the officer asks for. If a document does not exist, explain why in writing.
IRCC tells its officers to say which documents may be needed to answer their concerns.
An officer may cite A16(1) together with A41. A41 says a foreign national who breaks a rule of the Act is inadmissible. “Inadmissible” means not allowed to enter or stay in Canada.
An untrue answer about an important fact can also lead to A40, misrepresentation. The law then makes you inadmissible for five years (A40(2)(a)). If A40 appears in your notes, get legal advice first.
Section 16 also says you must come for an examination, such as an interview, if asked. For a foreign national, evidence includes photos and fingerprints. You must also do a medical exam if the rules require one.
What might your notes show?
Every file is different. Your decision note or GCMS notes may record:
- The date the officer asked for documents, and what was asked for
- Whether a reply arrived, and when
- What the officer thought of your documents or your answers
- Any link the officer made to A41 or A40
IRCC may hold back some lines.
Why do officers write A16(1)?
These situations can lead to it. Your notes, or the officer's decision note, may name the one in your case.
- A request for documents went to an old email or an agent, and nobody replied
- The reply came after the deadline in the letter
- Some of the documents asked for were missing, with no explanation
- An answer on a form or at an interview did not match your documents
- A form question answered wrongly, for example about a past refusal
- Not giving fingerprints and a photo, or not doing a medical exam, when asked
What can you fix before you apply again?
Answer the concern the officer actually named. Changing everything else at once can make a file look staged.
- Get your GCMS notes. They can show what the officer asked for, and when
- Check the email address and IRCC account on your file. Make sure you see every message
- Answer every question truthfully, even when the true answer looks bad
- Send every document asked for. If one does not exist, explain why in a short letter, with proof if you can
- Keep a copy of everything you send, and the date you sent it
- If your notes also mention A40, speak to a Canadian immigration lawyer or an RCIC first
Which weaknesses do officers cite under this ground?
These are the specific gaps that recur in refusals on this ground. IRCC does not publish a ranked list; this is a research-based classification, with the official sources for each.
Required forms or documents are missing or the application is incomplete
The personalized document checklist is not fully satisfied, forms are incomplete, key supporting evidence requested for the applicant’s situation is absent, or a later IRCC request for additional information is not answered adequately or on time.
Why the officer cares: IRCC instructs applicants to provide all documents on the personalized checklist and to respond to additional document requests used to establish admissibility. Incomplete applications or missed evidence requests can prevent the officer from being satisfied that the requirements are met.
How to strengthen a new application:
- Use a submission checklist and confirm every upload opens correctly. If IRCC later asks for more evidence, answer each item and keep proof of submission. If a document cannot be obtained, provide a truthful explanation and alternative evidence where appropriate rather than silently omitting it
Common mistakes:
- Blank required fields
- wrong file uploaded
- unsigned form where signature is required
- assuming a cover letter replaces mandatory evidence
- missing or only partly answering an IRCC request
Sources: IRCC — How to apply for a visitor visa, and supporting documents; IRCC — Avoid delays or refusals in processing an application
Passport or travel-document problems
The passport/travel document is expired, has insufficient validity, is not acceptable for the purpose, or the submitted copy does not include the required identity and visa/stamp pages.
Why the officer cares: IRPR 179 requires an acceptable passport or other document that can be used to enter the issuing country or another country. IRCC currently recommends a passport/travel document valid for at least six months from the planned travel date for visitor-visa applications.
How to strengthen a new application:
- Renew before applying where appropriate
- provide clear colour copies of the required pages
- explain legal name differences with supporting documents
Common mistakes:
- Applying with a passport about to expire while expecting a long-validity visa
- cropped identity page
- omitting old passport with relevant travel history
Sources: IRPR section 179 — Temporary Resident Visa issuance requirements; IRCC — How to apply for a visitor visa, and supporting documents
Biometrics are not provided when required or not provided on time
The applicant receives a biometric instruction request but fails to complete biometrics within the required period or follow the instructions.
Why the officer cares: IRCC specifically advises applicants to provide required biometrics promptly (generally within 30 days of the request) to avoid delays or refusal. Existing biometrics for visitor/work/study applications are generally valid for 10 years even if a prior application was refused.
How to strengthen a new application:
- Check existing biometric validity before filing and follow the current BIL. If circumstances prevent timely completion, use the proper IRCC channel rather than ignoring the deadline
Common mistakes:
- Assuming a previous refusal cancels valid biometrics
- attending without the correct instruction
- missing the deadline without contacting IRCC
Sources: IRCC — Avoid delays or refusals in processing an application; IRCC — Biometrics remain valid for 10 years, even after a refusal
Translations or certified copies do not meet IRCC requirements
Supporting evidence in a language other than English or French is uploaded without the required translation package or with an unacceptable translator.
Why the officer cares: IRCC states that, unless otherwise instructed, documents not in English or French must be accompanied by an English/French translation, an affidavit from the translator, and a certified photocopy of the original document.
How to strengthen a new application:
- Use a qualified translator and follow the current IRCC rules for the application type. Translate stamps/annotations that are material to the document where needed
Common mistakes:
- Applicant/family member translating their own document
- translating only selected lines
- missing affidavit or certified copy where required
Sources: IRCC — Supporting-document language and translation requirements
How can you see the officer's real reason?
IRCC now sends the officer's decision note with most refusals. That covers most temporary-resident refusals since 29 July 2025. It also covers most permanent-residence refusals since 26 May 2026.
IRCC sends the note with the refusal letter, to you or to your representative. It may remove some parts.
Your GCMS notes can show more. GCMS is IRCC's case system, and the notes are what officers wrote in it. They can include the case history and earlier notes. IRCC may hold back some lines.
You can ask IRCC for your own records yourself. It is free, from anywhere in the world, under Canada's Privacy Act. Since 13 July 2022, that right is “extended to include all individuals outside Canada”. See how to do it yourself.
Or we can file the records request for you: CAIPS Notes + Application File, ₹949C$59US$45, GST includedthe total we charge.
General information, not legal advice.Every file is different, and nothing here predicts the result of an application. We are not Canadian lawyers or RCICs. Our licence is from Punjab, India; it is not a Canadian licence. For a misrepresentation finding (A40), speak to a Canadian immigration lawyer or an RCIC first.
Get your notes
GST included. This is the total you pay.This is the total you pay.
Paid help is optional: you can always ask IRCC yourself, free.
Sources
- Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, s. 16(1), (1.1) and (2)laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/I-2.5/section-16.html
laws-lois.justice.gc.ca, text current to 3 September 2026 (opens in a new tab) - Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, section 41laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/I-2.5/section-41.html
laws-lois.justice.gc.ca, text current to 3 September 2026 (opens in a new tab) - Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, section 40laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/I-2.5/section-40.html
laws-lois.justice.gc.ca, text current to 3 September 2026 (opens in a new tab) - IRCC, Procedural fairness (instructions for IRCC staff)canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/corporate/publications-manuals/operational-bulletins-manuals/service-delivery/procedural-fairness.html
canada.ca, page dated 29 August 2023 (opens in a new tab) - IRCC, Officer decision notescanada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/corporate/transparency/officer-decision-notes.html
canada.ca, page dated 27 August 2026 (opens in a new tab) - Privacy Act Extension Order, No. 3 (SOR/2021-174), section 1laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/regulations/SOR-2021-174/FullText.html
laws-lois.justice.gc.ca, in force 13 July 2022; text current to 3 September 2026 (opens in a new tab) - IRCC Help Centre, Who can make a request under the Privacy Act?ircc.canada.ca/english/helpcentre/answer.asp?qnum=459&top=1
ircc.canada.ca, page dated 1 September 2026 (opens in a new tab) - IRCC, Request your personal information under the Privacy Act (no fees)canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/corporate/transparency/access-information-privacy/request-privacy-act.html
canada.ca, page dated 24 April 2018 (opens in a new tab)
